Diadenosine tetraphosphate (Ap4A) - an E. coli alarmone or a damage metabolite?

Under stress, metabolism is changing: specific up- or down-regulation of proteins and metabolites occurs as well as side-effects. Distinguishing specific stress-signaling metabolites (alarmones) from side-products (damage metabolites) is not trivial. One example is diadenosine tetraphosphate, Ap4A - a side-product of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases found in all domains of life. The earliest observations suggested that Ap4A serves as an alarmone for heat stress in E. coli. However, despite 50 years of research, the signaling mechanisms associated with Ap4A remain unknown. We defined a set of criteria for distinguishing alarmones from damage metabolites to systematically classify Ap4A. In a nutshell, no indications for a signaling cascade that is triggered by Ap4A were found; rather, we found that Ap4A is efficiently removed in a constitutive, non-regulated manner. Several-fold perturbations in Ap4A concentrations have no effect, yet accumulation at very high levels is toxic due to disturbance of zinc homeostasis, and also because Ap4A's structural overlap with ATP can result in spurious binding and inactivation of ATP binding proteins. Overall, Ap4A met all criteria for a damage metabolite. While we do not exclude any role in signaling, our results indicate that the damage metabolite option should be considered as the null hypothesis when examining Ap4A and other metabolites whose levels change upon stress.