Crafting the Future: Reimagining Artisanal Work in the Age of Digital Technologies

Extended Abstract:
Craft work is a contested and complex activity (Kettley, 2010; Bell et al., 2019) and is described as a practice that relies on combining renewal and tradition for continued success and growth (Popp & Holt, 2016; Gibson, 2016; Blundel & Smith, 2018). Recent studies on craft work suggest that craft-based businesses can capitalize from the opportunities afforded by technologies (e.g. Raffaelli, 2018). For example, in craft tailoring, cutting-edge sensing cubicles have been used to take body measurements with a follow-up phase where artisans work with customers in their homes to perfect the fit and finish of garments (Bell et al., 2021).
While emerging digital technologies have been incorporated in a variety of craft-based activities, less has been done to explore how such technologies challenge human abilities and creativity when introduced in work settings and how they redefine skills and the meanings of work. Being at the crossroads of manufacturing and creative industries (The Creative Industries Council, 2021; Scottish Government, 2010; UK Government, 2001), craft work is one of the most unexplored areas of research regarding the potential usage, implications, and consequences of digital technologies.
After the Industrial Revolution, starting from textile it has been impossible for many types of crafts to stay away from the invasion of machines and the process of mechanization (Kim, 2014). In fact, the rapid development of new industrial technologies throughout the 20th century has caused different types of craft work engage in diverse processes of combining hand and machine in their production processes, entering a constant struggle of how to balance authenticity and automation without losing the “artisanal” character of the product (Kroezen et al., 2021; Gandini & Gerosa, 2023). Yet, the incorporation of technologies and its reverberations on the craft work vary through time, place, culture and according to the product/activity of the craft itself. Making a substantial part of the creative economy (Luckman, 2015), craft companies are mostly family-owned, small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and craft sector is quite diverse, containing over 130 different professions (Hartmann, 2023) such as pottery masters, bakers, and musical instrument repairers. It is already clear that automation and intelligent machinery supported by artificial Intelligence (AI) have a strong potential in supporting the various aspects of craft processes, ranging from design and ideation (Kim & Maher, 2022) to production (Eskak & Salma, 2020) and marketing (Haleem et al., 2022). For instance, one of the core values of craft work is sustaining tailor-made, precise production satisfying each customer’s diverse needs and expectations, and digital technologies already can support craftsmen and craft business owners in saving time and resources and improving their products/services. Yet, as Moravec’s paradox argues, computers can do the things that human beings find difficult such as mathematics or logic at the far advanced level, but are not easy to be trained to learn the things that human beings find easy such as identifying faces, mobility etc. (Moravec, 1988). Artisanal work in general involves tasks that “require the sensor-motor intelligence of humans”, requiring unexpected problem-solving and decision-making processes on complex scenarios, which intelligent technologies of today cannot necessarily support (Hartmann, 2023, p. 223). Therefore, it becomes relevant to explore the relationship between handcraft, creativity and automated processes of production which result from technological developments.
What constitutes craft work – beyond its oppositional dualisms of hand/machine making