Data di Pubblicazione:
2012
Citazione:
CLAUSOLE DI FORMA E MERGER CLAUSES / F. Garatti ; tutor: F. Addis, E. Panzarini ; coordinatore: C. Tenella Sillani. Universita' degli Studi di Milano, 2012 Apr 18. 24. ciclo, Anno Accademico 2011. [10.13130/garatti-francesca_phd2012-04-18].
Abstract:
Art. 1352 of the Italian civil code is the only provision specifically dedicated to self-imposed contractual formalism.
However, many other provisions indirectly deal with requirements of form, therefore they must necessarily be coordinated with art. 1352.
Traditionally, civilians assimilate forms required by law with forms voluntarily adopted by parties, overlooking their deep ontological differences.
In an attempt to show the complexity of the research, the first part of the dissertation is an historical examination of formalism.
Art. 1352 c.c. is a defective provision; moreover self-adopted forms have also been underestimated by the italian legislator.
With this awareness, and without any pretense of completeness, it has been necessary to review the topic in a critical way to better describe a constantly evolving contractual practice.
The historical approach has been followed by a comparison of legal forms and self-imposed ones.
Teleologically oriented interpretation demonstrates the impossibility of applying the categories of legal formalism (for example the binomio forma ad probationem vs. forma ad substantiam) to self-imposed forms.
Since requirements of form can achieve different goals, they can not be described in a univocal way, except in a purely theoretical perspective.
The discussion of main problems originated from art. 1352 c.c. has led to the first conclusion: this provision is only a part of a wider and complex phenomenon; for this reason, it isn’t a general rule.
This clarification is the essential step to introduce the third issue addressed in the first chapter of this research, namely the nature of form agreements.
The analysis of the meaning of "clause" has been followed by a brief examination of main doctrinal theories, to underline the procedural nature of form agreements.
The functional approach suggests a careful analysis of interests that parties want to achieve imposing a particular form.
Since form terms are often imposed by one party on another, the better determination of the research subject has called for some observations about another very important issue, namely, the relationship between standard contracts and form agreements.
The second chapter, dealing with the phenomenon of standardization, wants to clarify whether a unilaterally imposed form term disappoints the weaker party’s expectations or, on the contrary, it’s an expression of the party freedom of contract.
This approach underlines the utility of a functionalist dimension, highlighting the multi-tasking role of forms.
With specific reference to standard contracts, the awareness of the protectionist trend shown by consumer legislator confirms the importance of this issue.
The second part of the chapter has been structured so as to identify specific law cases in standard form contracts that, without presenting the typical features of form terms, constraint the formal aspect of an agreement.
In particular, the research focuses on “subject to company approval” clause, notice of insurance claim and the notification of non-conformity in the regulation of the sale of consumer goods.
These three examples confirm how self-imposed forms can achieve different goals, namely limiting freedom of contract, limiting and excluding professional liability, reducing consumer rights.
Therefore, even if such clauses are different from form agreements, they must be under control of unfairness.
Consumer Code provides a description of self-imposed formalism far from the overview offered by italian Civil code.
For this reason it is important to take into consideration the relationship between Consumer and Civil code, in order to determine the meaning and the function of art. 33, c. 2, letter. q c. cons.- the only consumer provision
Tipologia IRIS:
Tesi di dottorato
Keywords:
formalismo convenzionale ; forme volontarie ; clausole di forma ; condizioni generali di contratto ; clausole vessatorie ; merger clauses ; entire agreement clauses
Elenco autori:
F. Garatti
Link alla scheda completa:
Link al Full Text: